Skip to main content

How to NOT expose a read only collection in C#

These days I had the opportunity to make a review over an ecommerce application. They tried to use CQRS and they almost succeeded. 
I notified a problem on their queries classes that can become a big problem in time, if you want to sell this solution as a platform. Also, from some perspective, these problems also violate the CQRS principle.
Let’s see some code now:
public class Order
{
    Collection<OrderItem> _items;   

    public IEnumerable<OrderItem> Items
    {
        get
        {
            return _items;
        }
    }
    ...
}
What do you see here strange?  We want to expose the OrderItem collection as a read only collection. To do this, we convert it to IEnumerable.
Hmmm… sounds good? Nope. Big mistake! Nobody stop us to convert the Items back to an ICollection and Add/Remove items from it.
Order order = new Order();
…
var orderItems = (Collection<OrderItem>)oder.Items;
What should we do? .NET framework has specials collections that can be used in these situations. I this case we should use IReadOnlyCollection<T>. This class will let the user to access items but he will not be able to modify the list (add or remove items from the collection).
To obtain the list as a read only collection we will need to use the AsReadOnly() method:
public class Order
{
    Collection<OrderItem> _items;   

    public IReadOnlyCollection<OrderItem> Items
    {
        get
        {
            return _items. AsReadOnly();
        }
    }
   
    ...
}
Under the hood, this method will create a new collection that point to our original items.
When expose items as “read-only”, you should always double check. There are many methods that permit us to cast items.

Comments

  1. What about the OrderItems themselves? You can't add or remove, but you can change the existing ones. How do you protect against that? Setting quantity to zero on an OrderItem (OrderLine) it's as if you deleted that item/line from the cart. Even today, to remove an item from your cart on Amazon you have to type zero in the quantity field and click "Update" :).

    ReplyDelete
  2. Encapsulating the internal collection with a ReadOnlyCollection clearly makes the intent more clear, but does not stops a programmer that is determined to break the encapsulation, by doing something like:

    IList orderItems = ((ReadOnlyCollection)(oder.Items)).Items;
    :-)

    ReplyDelete
  3. I thought that modifying the IEnumerable collection while iterating will cause runtime exception, isn't that right?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Windows Docker Containers can make WIN32 API calls, use COM and ASP.NET WebForms

After the last post , I received two interesting questions related to Docker and Windows. People were interested if we do Win32 API calls from a Docker container and if there is support for COM. WIN32 Support To test calls to WIN32 API, let’s try to populate SYSTEM_INFO class. [StructLayout(LayoutKind.Sequential)] public struct SYSTEM_INFO { public uint dwOemId; public uint dwPageSize; public uint lpMinimumApplicationAddress; public uint lpMaximumApplicationAddress; public uint dwActiveProcessorMask; public uint dwNumberOfProcessors; public uint dwProcessorType; public uint dwAllocationGranularity; public uint dwProcessorLevel; public uint dwProcessorRevision; } ... [DllImport("kernel32")] static extern void GetSystemInfo(ref SYSTEM_INFO pSI); ... SYSTEM_INFO pSI = new SYSTEM_INFO(

Azure AD and AWS Cognito side-by-side

In the last few weeks, I was involved in multiple opportunities on Microsoft Azure and Amazon, where we had to analyse AWS Cognito, Azure AD and other solutions that are available on the market. I decided to consolidate in one post all features and differences that I identified for both of them that we should need to take into account. Take into account that Azure AD is an identity and access management services well integrated with Microsoft stack. In comparison, AWS Cognito is just a user sign-up, sign-in and access control and nothing more. The focus is not on the main features, is more on small things that can make a difference when you want to decide where we want to store and manage our users.  This information might be useful in the future when we need to decide where we want to keep and manage our users.  Feature Azure AD (B2C, B2C) AWS Cognito Access token lifetime Default 1h – the value is configurable 1h – cannot be modified

What to do when you hit the throughput limits of Azure Storage (Blobs)

In this post we will talk about how we can detect when we hit a throughput limit of Azure Storage and what we can do in that moment. Context If we take a look on Scalability Targets of Azure Storage ( https://azure.microsoft.com/en-us/documentation/articles/storage-scalability-targets/ ) we will observe that the limits are prety high. But, based on our business logic we can end up at this limits. If you create a system that is hitted by a high number of device, you can hit easily the total number of requests rate that can be done on a Storage Account. This limits on Azure is 20.000 IOPS (entities or messages per second) where (and this is very important) the size of the request is 1KB. Normally, if you make a load tests where 20.000 clients will hit different blobs storages from the same Azure Storage Account, this limits can be reached. How we can detect this problem? From client, we can detect that this limits was reached based on the HTTP error code that is returned by HTTP